When planning a bathroom remodel in your Pittsburgh home, one of the biggest decisions you’ll face is whether to install a walk-in shower, keep or add a bathtub, or include both. This choice affects not only the functionality and aesthetics of your bathroom but also your daily routine, home value, and long-term satisfaction with the space. At JL Home Builders, we’ve helped countless Pittsburgh homeowners navigate this decision for their bathroom projects, and we’re here to guide you through the process.
Understanding Your Options
Before diving into the pros and cons, it’s important to understand what each option offers. A walk-in shower typically features a curbless or low-threshold entry, glass enclosure, and modern tile work that creates a spa-like atmosphere. Bathtubs range from standard alcove tubs to freestanding soaking tubs and whirlpool options. Some homeowners opt for a tub-shower combination to maximize functionality in smaller spaces.
The Case for Walk-In Showers
Walk-in showers have become increasingly popular in Pittsburgh bathroom remodels, and for good reason. They offer a sleek, contemporary look that can make even small bathrooms feel more spacious and luxurious. The open design eliminates the visual barrier of a shower curtain or tub surround, creating better flow and making the room feel larger.
From a practical standpoint, walk-in showers are easier to access than bathtubs, which is especially important for aging-in-place considerations. Pittsburgh’s many historic homes with smaller bathrooms benefit from the space-saving design of a well-planned walk-in shower. They’re also easier to clean and maintain than bathtubs, with fewer surfaces where soap scum and mildew can accumulate.
Modern walk-in showers can be customized with features like rainfall showerheads, body sprays, built-in benches, and multiple shower niches for storage. These upgrades create a spa-like experience that many Pittsburgh homeowners find worth the investment.
The Benefits of Bathtubs
Despite the popularity of walk-in showers, bathtubs still hold significant value for many Pittsburgh families. If you have young children, a bathtub is nearly essential for bath time. Many parents find that trying to bathe small children in a shower is impractical and frustrating.
Bathtubs also provide relaxation opportunities that showers simply can’t match. After a long day or during Pittsburgh’s cold winters, a hot bath can be the perfect way to unwind. Soaking tubs and whirlpool options enhance this experience even further.
From a resale perspective, having at least one bathtub in your home is often recommended, especially in family-friendly Pittsburgh neighborhoods. Many real estate experts suggest that homes without any bathtubs can be harder to sell, particularly to buyers with young children or those who simply prefer having the option.
Key Considerations for Pittsburgh Homes
Several factors specific to Pittsburgh homes should influence your decision. Many of our area’s older homes have smaller bathrooms where space is at a premium. In these situations, a walk-in shower often makes more sense than trying to squeeze in both a tub and shower.
Pittsburgh’s aging housing stock also means that many homeowners are thinking about long-term accessibility. Walk-in showers with low or no thresholds are much safer and more accessible for people with mobility challenges. If you plan to age in place, a walk-in shower is typically the better choice.
Consider how many bathrooms your home has. If you have multiple bathrooms, you might install walk-in showers in some and keep a bathtub in at least one. This gives you the best of both worlds and maintains your home’s appeal to a broader range of potential buyers if you eventually sell.
The Compromise: Tub-Shower Combinations
If you’re truly torn between the two options or working with limited space, a tub-shower combination might be your best solution. Modern tub-shower combos have come a long way from the basic fiberglass surrounds of the past. With quality tile work, frameless glass doors, and thoughtful design, you can create an attractive space that serves both functions.
This option is particularly popular in Pittsburgh homes with only one bathroom or in primary bathrooms where homeowners want maximum flexibility. Just keep in mind that tub-shower combinations require more maintenance than standalone walk-in showers and may not achieve the same high-end, spa-like aesthetic.
Making Your Decision
To make the best choice for your Pittsburgh home, consider these questions: Who lives in your home now, and what are their needs? Do you have young children who need bathing, or elderly family members who would benefit from easier shower access? How many bathrooms does your home have? What’s your budget for the remodel? How long do you plan to stay in your home?
Your answers to these questions will help clarify which option makes the most sense. At JL Home Builders, we work closely with Pittsburgh homeowners to understand their specific needs, lifestyle, and goals for their bathroom remodels.
Professional Installation Matters
Regardless of whether you choose a walk-in shower, bathtub, or combination, professional installation is crucial for long-term success. Proper waterproofing, drainage, and tile work are essential to prevent water damage and ensure your new bathroom looks beautiful and functions perfectly for years to come.
Pittsburgh’s climate, with its humidity and temperature fluctuations, makes proper bathroom construction even more important. Amateur installations often lead to water damage, mold problems, and costly repairs down the road.
Ready to transform your Pittsburgh bathroom? Whether you’re leaning toward a walk-in shower, bathtub, or combination, JL Home Builders can help you make the best decision for your home and bring your vision to life. Contact us today to discuss your bathroom remodeling project and get a free consultation.
